Water first: Study urges prioritizing irrigation and water management over genetic drought tolerance

As climate change intensifies droughts worldwide, a new perspective published in Agricultural Ecology and Environment argues that the most effective defense against crop failures is not genetic engineering but better water management.

The study, led by researchers from the Chinese Academy of Sciences and Princeton University, highlights a critical reality: plants cannot survive without a minimum water supply, no matter how drought-tolerant their genes may be. While decades of breeding have produced crop varieties that cope better with dry conditions, extreme droughts in recent years have still devastated harvests across Asia, Africa, Europe, and the Americas.

“Genetic improvements are valuable, but they cannot overcome the laws of plant physiology,” said lead author Sha Zhang. “Without water, photosynthesis and reproduction simply cannot occur. That is why effective water management must come first.”

The paper points to several recent examples. In the United States, the 2012 drought slashed corn and sorghum yields by nearly 30 percent despite widespread use of drought-tolerant hybrids. In Argentina, the 2022–2023 drought reduced soybean and peanut production by over 40 percent. Similar losses were seen in Zambia, China, and Western Europe, where genetic advances provided little protection once soil moisture fell below critical thresholds.

By contrast, integrated water management strategies have consistently stabilized or boosted yields. Practices such as modern irrigation systems, rainwater harvesting, soil mulching, and conservation tillage improve water availability and resilience. In Burkina Faso, farmers more than doubled crop yields using simple techniques like contour stone bunds and planting pits, without relying on new crop varieties.

The authors stress that genetic and water-based approaches should be seen as complementary rather than competing. Drought-tolerant crops perform best when combined with measures that ensure sufficient soil moisture. For example, pairing improved maize varieties with deficit irrigation in India increased yields by around 20 percent compared to conventional crops under the same conditions.

The study calls for urgent investment in irrigation modernization, rainwater harvesting, soil health restoration, and stronger water governance. These measures not only enhance agricultural resilience but also deliver environmental co-benefits, such as reducing methane emissions from rice fields through water-saving irrigation practices.

“Food security in a hotter, drier world depends on water first,” said co-author Yuang Guo. “Biotechnology will play a role, but it cannot substitute for the infrastructure and policies needed to ensure reliable water access.”

The researchers conclude that a fundamental shift in priorities is needed. Instead of treating water management as a secondary measure, it should be placed at the center of climate adaptation strategies. Only then can genetic advances reach their full potential and help safeguard global food supplies.

=== 

Journal Reference: Zhang S, Guo Y. 2025. Water first: why effective water management outweighs genetic drought tolerance in agricultural adaptation. Agricultural Ecology and Environment 1: e004 https://www.maxapress.com/article/doi/10.48130/aee-0025-0002  

=== 

About Agricultural Ecology and Environment: 

Agricultural Ecology and Environment is a multidisciplinary platform for communicating advances in fundamental and applied research on the agroecological environment, focusing on the interactions between agroecosystems and the environment. It is dedicated to advancing the understanding of the complex interactions between agricultural practices and ecological systems. The journal aims to provide a comprehensive and cutting-edge forum for researchers, practitioners, policymakers, and stakeholders from diverse fields such as agronomy, ecology, environmental science, soil science, and sustainable development. 

Follow us on Facebook, X, and Bluesky.